CONFLICT BETWEEN JUSTICES AND INJUSTICES

LOVE IS ULTIMATE SOLUTION

Reservation is a very sensitive subject in INDIA and nobody wants to discuss about this topic whereas when it comes to take the advantage of reservation, everyone want to get it as it has huge advantage in government as well as educational sectors. And on the background of recent economic and caste census, the subject has become more explosive. We need to look it in very objective way.

So before going deep into the present scenario , we should look why this law has made because we can’t solve any problem within going deeper into it , we should know why this rule has made , what the benefits and how it is miss utilize in present time .

I know everyone know this fact, everyone discuss this fact too openly but no one is as blunt and dauntless as I am, I just want to make something clear about it. I want to make everyone equal, that’s my prime duty, I want everyone should love everyone and this is the only way to solve this problem but don’t take all kinds of advantage in one time.

Reservation quota law

India is the world’s largest democracy with diversity culture, yet in spite of this, it always been subjected to a major controversies owing to the caste system. This was the major issue before independence even now also , the only difference is before independent – caste issue was literally killing some group of people or they bounds to lose their dignity through their caste , whereas now a days it become a major weapon for many even for political parties too like vote bank policy .

Now, the question remains still there - whether this has been beneficial or if it has led to further enhancement of the differences?

1.     The purpose of reservation: to address the historic oppression, inequality and discrimination faced by members of the Dalit and other communities, creating great social, economic and political disadvantage against them. After independence, reservation was felt necessary.

a.     Do all of the crores of reserved category people deserve reservation? I don’t think as now those reserved categories are getting benefited their family is improving whereas those who are in still in rural areas , now also their condition is poor and they are not getting any kind of proper benefit of the government . so I think - Instead the system should not allow all under this reservation category ,like if your parents are belongs to IAS officer then what’s the need of reservation category to become your children IAS officer , better give a change to general poor category student who really need it badly . who struggle hard to reach into this level whereas RICH reservation categories just enjoy their life and happy with less hard labour as they are getting what they are expecting, so I think reservation should be on the basis of family education or income etc. to get unnecessary benefit and let the real victims get opportunity to uplift.

b.     Second-generation exemption: Suppose someone gets admission in college using quota well it’s fair enough for poor kids or poor family background whereas it’s not fair enough for a person from rich background with well standard of education. Now, he/she can say that he has been given equal opportunity for his career. But, again he/she uses quota to become an IAS.

Do you think so, do he need it? Absolutely not. Anyway, now he/she has become financially, socially and politically powerful. But his/her son and daughter also uses quota for college and IAS. And this cycle keeps repeating. 

Does it make any sense if second (or third) generation keeps exploiting this leverage?

c.      Mark basis - if some OBC, SC or ST category student scores less marks than a General category student, it’s because his great grandfather was oppressed?

Identifying right beneficiaries:

1. OBC (27% Reservation)

There is very serious flaw in OBC - Creamy layer principle; as we see in our surroundings, anyone can take the creamy layer certificate. Economically very sound person have non creamy layer certificates. And the real benefits are taken by the same people again and again. Also as OBC is a politically active and organized caste. The government gives in every time and revises the Creamy layer criteria. So the real benefits never percolates downwards.
For Example: - The non-creamy layer income criteria today is about 6 lakhs per annum (50 K / month), now in our country where half of the population is below and nearby the poverty line, the person with 50k salary is considered backward. Is this justifiable?  Also there is a dire need to look into OBC's further as certain OBC sections are in dire need of reservations but the benefits doesn't reach them. So there must be some classification in OBC's and the reservation must be provided accordingly.

Also there must be a timely ban on revising creamy-layer criteria.

Tamilnadu is a shining example here, the exclusion principle is followed very effectively in Tamilnadu so that same sections of OBC society does not take advantage of the reservation policy. The well placed and affluent OBC's are excluded in TamilNadu by a clear and transparent procedure.

2) SC:    (15 % Reservation)

Now we must bring the principal of non-creamy layer based reservation system in SC's also.

Now please don't argue that the Hon Courts have said that the income is not a criteria for backwardness among SC's. In todays globalised world, economy decides your status, denial of this fact is a sign of hypocrisy!

If a creamy layer criteria is 6 lakhs for OBC's you keep say 25 or 50 lakhs for SC's but keep something. So that at least 0.0005 % of creamy people from that section will be excluded and the reservation will be peculated downwards.

3) ST:   (7.5 % Reservation)

The condition of Adivasi’s in all over India is critical. They are the most exploited societies.
So we must accommodate them in the development activity by enhancing their participation in every single aspects -- education, administration, jobs, politics,

Panchayat Raj institutes etc.

As general observation is that ST's are unaware of the benefits and schemes, it is must for the government to educate them and come out with the time bound plan of their overall development.

And if the demand of the situation is such that there is a need to give them more reservations then it can be provided

THE REAL POOR:

In today's world, the economy drives everything. So those who are poor but unfortunately don't belong to any reservation caste, they suffer the most in this system.

However, the present system can be modified:

I agree that the system is flawed enough as it is, I think in every system has its own flaws. so few steps can be taken to solve that problem so that people get their proportional representation and educate themselves faster as well as FAIR AND JUSTICES will be well applicable here.

·         Reservation will be based on economic status, social status, location and then keep reservations and poverty-alleviation programs based on this new list.

·         Judge the development of reservation category after 20 yrs., after they develop remove them out from reservation category but few facilities can be given to get proper dignity in society.

·         Remove castes first and after that abolish reservation.

Remove the caste system is best way to get rid of reservation system, this only can bring equality and justices in society.

But removing caste is not as easy as it seems, there are many higher caste group who surely oppose this too as they love their background a lot. Removal of castes will result in an awful lot of confusion (not to mention loss of vote banks for various political parties) and is not feasible.

AFFECTS THE SOCIETY -

1.     Discrimination against General category: 

Going by the logic of people who support reservation, General category is been discriminated for last 70 years. So, shall reverse the scenario and give reservation to General Category? Article 14, 15(1), 16(1) and 16(2) of Constitution assures us equality of status and opportunity which is totally contradictory to reservation system. Article 16(2) clearly says “No citizen shall, on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth, residence or any of them, be ineligible for, or discriminated against in respect or, any employment or office under the State.”

2.     Growing rage: 

Reservation is growing rage slowly, especially among youngsters who don’t get college seats and jobs despite their hard work. India should no way make stupid mistakes like Sri Lanka did. We all know how a college protest (Tamil New Tigers converted into a militant organization LTTE) against reservation turned into a civil war which left overall 60,000–100,000 killed (estimate) and 800,000 displaced at peak in 2001. Every year there are protests, people demanding “either give us reservation or remove the reservation”. Human rage cannot be estimated or controlled especially under violent leadership like Jet reservation (more than 30 deaths and a loss of ₹340 billion). So, we need to stop before agitation bursts out on streets.

My personal view or my experience-

Now in INDIA job deficit is due to lack of skills and knowledge just because of 50% RESERVATION QUOTA as I already mentioned as per the coat reservation.

INDIA WILL RISE WHEN EVERYONE WILL GET TRUE JUSTICES OF THEIR WORK - I wish to see a better INDIA where there will be no more reservation system , if it'll b then that will based on economic status and family status not randomly , so that fair justices can b happen , people will get what they deserve . Wish! FUTURE Indian Reservation system will be wash out from academic as well as Job career: D

I am not saying just because I am from Brahmin caste even my best friends are also from reservation category and I love them so much , still they can understand GENERAL CATEGORY PEOPLE'S pain so they also indirectly support me .

I am against this as this may be the main reason why I couldn’t get medical and my favorite branch as well as college too (I am not saying I am too talented otherwise I could get it but I am not that much capable to get top positions in competitive exams but I failed in last ranks where there was a sure chance if I would be a reservation category , as in medical general category only 250 seats are there and I was near to it , My Engineering registration number to important links - https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=867155033373391&set=a.106808729408029.20035.100002367085874&type=3&theater  , https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=840820499340178&set=a.106808729408029.20035.100002367085874&type=3&theater  , https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=629460937142803&set=a.106808729408029.20035.100002367085874&type=3&theater , https://www.facebook.com/sweta.panda/media_set?set=a.483215735100658.1073741836.100002367085874&type=3 
actually these are presently available proofs i have as rest either i thrown or something happened with that when i didn't get like MEDICAL . These certificates as well as documents are saved as i kept it in my book or some non important file that's why :P . This engineering rank i have got based on PHYSICS AND CHEMISTRY MARK AS I DIDN'T APPEAR MATH AS I WAS SURE THAT I'LD GET MEDICAL AS MY BIO PAPER WAS AFTER MATH PAPER THAT'S WHY I COMPLETED IT EARLY AND LEFT CLASS 45 minutes before the exam finish by requesting investigator FOR MY NEXT BIOLOGY EXAM , OJEE STUDENTS KNOW IT VERY WELL WHO APPEAR BOTH FOR MEDICAL AND ENGINEERING EXAMS IN DAY AND 1 HOUR GAP . I APPEARED ENGINEERING BECAUSE OF MY PAPA'S REQUEST , AS HE LOVE TO KEEP BROAD OPTIONS , FOR HIM ONLY I APPEARED AIEEE TOO WHERE AS I HAD ONLY ONE OPTION THAT IS MEDICAL. My papa is a kind of my life saver for me otherwise i don't know what gonna happen in my life ) .

I am not here to make anyone's dignity less but it hampering many people in INDIA.

IF YOU CAN MARRY FROM OTHER CASTE WHY YOU CAN'T STOP THIS RESERVATION QUOTA FROM EDUCATION TO GOVERNMENT SECTOR JOBS. IF IT IS INJUSTICES THEN FALLING IN LOVE AND MARRIAGE DON'T YOU THINK INJUSTICES? Think from mind not from heart.

Let’s create a better society with NO RESERVATION QUOTA , LOVE AND MARRY ALL OPENLY THAT IS GRANTED and ACCEPTABLE BUT DON'T TAKE ADVANTAGE OF EDUCATION AND JOB EVERY TIME , THAT'S NOT TOLERABLE EVERY TIME.

Of course this is our main dignity, love is from heart but after that you need money and your job to SURVIVE in society. Who else don’t want to live a dignify life - I hope everyone else, so why should we compromise here. Love has no bar but self-respect also matters who people point out on your labor and talent. Every time you can’t play reservation blame game. This is the real fact.

Hope u all agree with me!!!

The constitution of INDIA - Major source - http://lawmin.nic.in/coi/coiason29july08.pdf

PS : THE STATISTICAL DATA ARE COPIED FROM QUORA AND OTHER SITES and special information about Tamilnadu is got from QUORA , that just for example purpose . I respect all place . if you have doubt search by yourself .